With classic Sicilian nods to their Pomodori Secchi Ripieni (stuffed sundried tomatoes), Sicilian Antipasto (fried chickpeas with ricotta and grated cheese), Capanotina (eggplant salad), and of course Polpo All'Insalata (cold seafood salad), it can be daunting in deciding what to order. If youre a pesto person, the Pesto di Rucola e Pistaccio is your dish. Made in their coal-fired oven, the pizzas here have a crispy exterior and a distinctive taste and chewiness in the crust. Yes, its simple, but the perfect execution makes it a great appetizer. Also located on Staten Island is the acclaimed Italian restaurant Pier 76. In 1950, nearly half of the more than 10,000 New Yorkers living in the heart of Little Italy identified as Italian-American. Main article: Where in New York should you stay? Where to Eat. Come and join us for a taste of Italy. The Pollo Rollatini has a beautifully cooked, crunchy chicken cutlet stuffed with salty prosciutto and fresh mozzarella, and the marsala mushroom sauce is luxuriously sweet and savory. Russ & Daughters: Open Since The 1910s. One of New York's oldest and most exclusive restaurants, Rao's is known as much for its old-school Italian food as the famous faces it feeds. Welcome to Paesano's of Mulberry Street. Year Opened: 1950 La Mela is famous as a staple of Mulberry Street in New York's Little Italy. Location: 278 Bleecker Street, New York City My grandfather used to go back to Naples every year to participate in the Festival of Piedigrotta, Rossi said of the now-defunct music festival which began in the 1800s. Alleva was a great store. The menu features classic favorites such as pasta carbonara, beef braciole, and tiramisu, as well as a range of daily specials. The mussels are highly recommended. Fortunately, Jose Luis has mastered this craft, and they offer some of the most authentic ones right here in Little Italy, NY. I want to thank everyone for their love and support.. Bon apptit! Some folks rush to retirement, collecting their 401Ks by age 65 and perhaps relocating to Florida for an easy, laid-back life. The bestseller is the Favoloso, piled high with salame toscano, pecorino cream, artichoke cream, and spicy eggplant, but for something funky, go for the Sweet Treat For The Fall, a monstrous sandwich with lardo, truffle honey, and gorgonzola. Finding authentic paella, or at least something close, is pretty hard. Pizzamaker Vito at J&V Pizzeria in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn. What to order: Valenciana Paella, Pesto di Rucola e Pistaccio, Gambas Al Ajillo, Address: 115 Mulberry Street, New York, NY 10013. The casual, family-friendly atmosphere welcomes you to dine on The Best Coal Brick Oven Pizza, or one of the delicious items on the menu.Specialties include lobster fra diavolo, baby lamb chops and veal chops. In his book, "A Very Punchable Face," Colin Jost, a local Staten Islander, goes as far as to say even the Irish, Arabic, and Vietnamese communities in Staten Island naturally become Italian just for living there. The earthy and umami truffle cream on the side is the perfect dip for these fried risotto balls. Featuring a glass-enclosed garden dining area that feels intimate and romantic, and professional old-school waiters serving the restaurants signature dishes paired with Italian wine, this venue is perfect for a date. Vets. Were a New York institution, King said. Given below are the top 10 little Italy restaurants to visit . Dont leave without trying the bacon cheeseburger that Nat King Cole once deemed the Cadillac of burgers.. Your email address will not be published. New York City Passes What is the Best Attraction Pass for You in 2023? On Saturday morning, the old heart of the neighborhood took another hit when a fire broke out at Angelo's of Mulberry St., said to be the oldest Italian restaurant in the area. Lunellas Bruschetta con Zucchine will make you realize what youve been missing out on! This fine-dining restaurant and event space, located on the 65th floor of 30 Rock, was originally opened back in 1934. It's been delighting New Yorkers with the classic hamburger in its true and simplest form since 1961 and have now expanded to several locations around the citythough its very first location in the West Village is still in existence. 1. 1905 | NYC Since 1905 Gennaro Lombardi crafted pizza in the United States using his bakers trade he learned from Naples. By the way:youll find many more New York City spots in ourLoving New York travel guides! TBH, Little Italy does have some amazing restaurants serving genuinely delicious Italian staples, you just need to know where to look. This intimate eatery serves up delicious Italian dishes made with the freshest ingredients, along with a selection of fine wines. Year Opened: 1924 RELATED: 10 Dishes That Will Make You Book A Flight To Italy. This story has been shared 112,868 times. 30 Rockefeller Plaza, 65th floor; rainbowroom.com, The 21 Most Stunning Wedding Venues in NYC. It's worth the trek to dine at Giuliana's Ristorante; the food standing on its own makes Giuliana's a great spot, especially with dishes like Artichoke Giuliana (fried artichoke and fried spinach in a gorgonzola cream sauce) and Frangelico chicken (almond-crusted chicken with a Frangelico liqueur sauce topped with veggies), but if the array of dishes offered isn't enough, the prices will remind diners that they're not in Manhattan anymore. More Best NYC Old-School Italian Restaurants. Where: 181 Grand St. 5. What: Feel free to venture out of your comfort zone here. The interior is lined with welcoming sidewalk tables, warmly decorated and designed to provide you an unforgettable, romantic ambiance. Lee's Restaurant. Current Owner(s): Adem Brija Contact: +1 212-965-0500. Our rich and famous history. Sign up to our newsletter for the latest and greatest from your city, Dont Be FooledThis New Italian Restaurant Isnt Exactly An Italian Restaurant, 14 Best Jazz Clubs In NYC For An Evening Of Live Music, 15 Experiences To Gift The Most Memorable Days Out In NYC, An Epic Japanese Food Fest Is Coming To NYC This Month. An expertly crafted wood-fire oven crackles and glows, cooking house-made dough into perfect, crisp Neapolitan-style pizza while creating an inviting atmosphere. What: This star studded restaurant doesnt take reservations, so if you dont want to wait too long its best to go early. New York has a lot of eateries, but these classic Italian old-school joints will make you feel like you're eating in your nonna's kitchen. Don't be surprised if you run into a celebrity here; it's a common spot for celebrity sightings, which the restaurant proudly boasts with its photo wall of those that have dined there in the past. It is the original home of Vincent's Sauce. Sasso and his family continued to run Johns until 1954 when the pizzeria was sold to the Augustine and Joe Vesce, who were distantly related to Sasso. The Lancieris opened Patsys in 1933 in East Harlem and the restaurant has remained there ever since. The Fettuccine Alfredo with chicken here is so delicious, youd want a second plate of the same right away! The selection of Italian restaurants in Little Italy is unsurprisingly large so theres bound to be something for you! The homey and comfortable environment is ideal for family-style group dining, and casual lunch and drinks with friends. Anthony (Totonno) Pero, who founded Totonnos Pizzeria Napolitano in 1924, immigrated to America in 1903 and worked for Gennaro Lombardi, who is credited with bringing pizza to America. New York Post - Hannah Frishberg 10h. Fresh homemade rigatoni is stuffed with cheese and tossed in a pink cream sauce with chicken. His grandfather would scout both tunes and talent, leading him to launch his own publishing company. Either way, youll end the meal with a powdered sugar zeppole. After years of evolution and recipes passed down from generation to generation, including their famous "gal-ah-mah" (calamari), Randazzo's Clam Bar was born. The restaurant is complete with a wine and sangria bar, and this is one of those places where you can see a diverse array of people, from tourists to New Yorkers. In addition to traditional dining service, other options include a glass of wine with antipasti, a family style meal at a communal table or a pizza and prosecco break. The Empire State Building: Is it worth going up to the 102nd floor? Baker and importer of over 200 superb Italian specialties, Ferrara dates its origins to 1892 when Caf Ferrara first opened its doors in New York City's Little Italy for opera lovers seeking likeminded company and refreshment. Petto di Pollo alla Emilio is an indulgent dish. Its. Price of Margherita or Cheese Pizza: $18.50 (small) or $22.50 (large). Dine-in and enjoy the convivial atmosphere and good service, or order your food for takeout or delivery. The portion sizes were so large . Mario's is the oldest restaurant in one of the most intact Little Italy's in the United States On a recent visit, Joe Migliucci, Mario's son, overlooked the dining room from the kitchen. are made the traditional way, using only the freshest local ingredients. Current Owner(s): Stella, John, and Joseph Mortillaro Try the montanara, perhaps the most popular menu item, a fried dough topped with tomato sauce, imported smoked buffalo mozzarella, and basil. Working at Lombardis made Pero the first ever pizzaiolo in America. Three sandwiches stacked from New York's All'Antico Vinaio, 14 Best Old-School Italian Restaurants In New York City, The City of 'Za: 10 Best Pizza Places in NYC, 10 Dishes That Will Make You Book A Flight To Italy, consider going on a pizzeria tour of the Big Apple, Uncover Hidden Gems: 10 Unique Tours In Charleston, 10 Most Exclusive Myrtle Beach Resorts Where You Can Stay In The Lap Of Luxury, 10 Top-Rated Resorts In The Phoenix Area: Unwind In The Desert Oasis Of Arizona's Stunning Capital, Georgia's College Town: The Ultimate Guide To Athens & Things To Do, A Historic & Academic Haven: The Ultimate Guide To Chapel Hill & Things To Do, Sail Away To Paradise: Uncovering Mexico's 10 Most Beautiful Oceanic Hideaways, Upstate New York's Rich Heritage: A Creative Tour To Uncover Its 10 Best Festivals, Fairs, & Cultural Events, Sunshine State Savings: 10 Affordable Florida Hotels For Your Next Vacation. The pasta has the perfect texture, and the cheese occupies your mouth every time you take a bite. I have plans to open a new location and continue the Alleva legacy, King said. Sofias of Little Italy is all about classic Italian food. Sometimes people dont come in to buy anything, but rather to say hello and say, Im happy to see youre still here, he said. What to order: Burrata, Grilled Cheese, Roasted Prawns, Cacio e Pepe Popcorn, Address: 249 Centre Street, New York, NY 10013. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. When you order Spaghetti Pomodoro here, remember to add meatballs at an extra cost. While the pomodoro sauce tastes fresh and flavorful with the al-dente spaghetti, the large, soft, and juicy meatballs definitely add their signature to the dish. The thinly pounded chicken is breaded just right to give it a crunchy exterior, while the inside is still juicy and extremely tender. Buona Notte is where a tempting menu, a welcoming ambience and Italian tradition converge in a superb culinary experience that will awaken all your senses prepared by Executive Chef Salvatore Fichera. Naturally, no one can actually say they are wrong without going there and trying it for themselves. Allevia was in Chapter 11 bankruptcy after accumulating about $628,00 dollars in back rent since the start of the pandemic. Their best-sellers are their orecchiette in rabbit ragu, a nod to the Puglia region from which Dora originates, and their pappardelle del ristoro with wild boar. And for a dollar Id buy five slices of Sicilian pizza and a couple of Cokes.. Especially in summer Da Nico is a popular restaurant because of the many outdoor seating possibilities. Of course, you could go classic and enjoy the beautifully done Margherita, or take the pasta route and try the Sunchoke Tortelli, an interesting but extremely tasty flavor combination of hazelnut, sage, and balsamic. Current Owner (s): The Denino and Burke Family. As Little Italy has shrunk, Lombardi's is now slightly outside the main strip of Italian restaurants on Mulberry Street but is a not to be missed experience. We New Yorkers are pretty spoiled when it comes to dining out. Inspired by the Roman pasta dish, the Cacio e Pepe Popcorn is a salty, cheesy, and peppery snack you can enjoy with any drink you choose. Known to be one of the oldest Italian restaurants in New York City is Bamonte's, in the heart of Brooklyn's North Williamsburg. Although Deninos Pizzeria & Tavern originally opened in 1937, the restaurant did not start serving pizza until 1951. Tel: 212-203-2766. Restaurants. Start of your trip: We will remind you with current events when you are in NYC! Location: 2155 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island It's sometimes difficult to find the best places to eat in Little Italy, NYC, as many are tourist traps that serve up average food that's not worth the cash. Old Homestead is the city's oldest steakhouse beating out both Peter Luger's and Keens. When this famous shop first opened its doors in 1914, it was known as an appetizing store, aka store that sells "the food one eats with bagels.". >>. The restaurants award-winning menu features a surprising selection of fresh salads, homemade pasta dishes and chef crafted entres. Register now - its free! As a result, E. Rossi and Co. became an American gatekeeper for music from the old country, including the Neapolitan genre dubbed the Sceneggiata. Back then, McSorleys was a men-only pubone of the last of its kindnot allowing women through its doorsuntil 1970. Denino's Pizzeria & Tavern. I'm a true New York fan! A taste of Southern Naples is what's on the menu at this Harlem institution, whose 1896 birth date makes it one of the country's oldest family-owned locales and still in the location where it first opened! Today, Nunzios is owned by Robert Whiteaker. Insert Giorgia Caporuscio of Manhattan's Don Antonio. Umberto's Clam House - Opened in 1972, today this seafood restaurant is run by the family's second generation. But the tourists who amble by tipsy on Campari and full from pasta might want to give it a second look. The narrow streets teemed with children and resonated . 2324 Arthur Ave Bronx, NY 10458. Nestled in the heart of Little Italy, Paesano's epitomizes Italian culture and charm. Note: apart from the a la carte menu, Puglia also offers pre-fixed dinner menus featuring their signature dishes that will be served family-style. Many, McDonalds is one of the biggest and most successful fast food franchises in the world. Robert Sietsema/Eater NY. 612 Crescent Avenue Bronx, NY 10458. The Tagliatelle alla Bolognese is a people pleaser. These risotto balls are crispy and crunchy on the outside and have a flavorful mushroom risotto filling inside. Umberto's roots reach back to 1972, when Ianniello's father first opened the restaurant's doors. I have to say it, theyve been very patient so far and Im sure well be able to work something out, he said. Patsy died in the 1970s and Carmella took over running the pizzeria. While the former is made following a 60-year-old family recipe, the latter is a well-made instant favorite. Patsys was immediately a hit with New Yorkers and the Lancieris had to buy the two adjacent buildings to keep up with demand. Quaint but cozy, they are known for their veteran status, having been run by a single family in the same location since 1891. Back before the Revolutionary War, this tavern served as a meeting spot for locals and travelers to come together and share their ideas about liberty, good food and everything in between.